Description:

Review

David Sedaris has spent three decades building a comic persona so distinct that it now arrives with its own set of expectations: the arched eyebrow, the precise inventory of human absurdity, the family as a cabinet of grotesques, the narrator himself as a fussy, self-absorbed, and improbably lovable crank. Calypso, his tenth collection, initially seems to deliver exactly this. It opens in West Sussex, Christmas 2012, the author proudly enumerating the two guest rooms in his sixteenth-century stone cottage and the choreography of the "perfect couple" performance he and his partner Hugh stage for visitors. The tone is arch, domestic, comfortable. And then it cracks open. By the second essay, Sedaris’s youngest sister Tiffany has killed herself, and the book becomes something stranger, rawer, and more consequential than anything he has written before. Calypso is the work of a humorist who has discovered, in late middle age, that his signature weapons—irony, detachment, the gag that preempts genuine feeling—cannot fully protect him from grief, guilt, and the accumulating losses of mortality. The book’s real achievement is not that it is funny, though it often is, but that it repeatedly lets you see the man behind the mask failing to keep it in place.

The collection’s central wound is Tiffany’s suicide in May 2013, which Sedaris announces in the essay “Now We Are Five” with a sentence that lands like a blow: “I felt I’d lost the identity I’d enjoyed since 1968, when my brother was born.” That identity—eldest of six, member of the sprawling, brawling Sedaris clan—is the foundation of his entire project. Family, for Sedaris, has been the inexhaustible raw material for a career built on comic exaggeration and affectionate contempt. But Tiffany’s death is not material he can easily shape into a punchline. She had been estranged from the family for years, living on disability in Somerville, Massachusetts, after a troubled adolescence that included time at a now-notorious behavioral institution. Her will forbade the family from having her body or attending her memorial. In the aftermath, Sedaris writes that the family is “the only club I’d ever wanted to be a member of,” and then, driving back from a Thanksgiving at the new beach house, he tries to fathom her exit: “to want out so badly that you’d take your own life?” The question is genuine, but the essay’s power lies in what it cannot resolve—the gap between his insistence on family-as-sanctuary and the evidence that he, personally, denied sanctuary to the one sibling who most needed it.

That evidence surfaces repeatedly, and it is the book’s most damning self-indictment. Sedaris recounts that the last time he saw Tiffany, at a stage door in Boston four years before her death, he ordered a security guard to close the door in her face. “The door,” he repeats in “The Spirit World,” in a memory so precise it vibrates with suppressed horror. “I’d like for you to close it now.” He and Tiffany hadn’t spoken for eight years. He had told himself she was “someone else’s problem.” This is not the comic self-deprecation of the earlier books, where Sedaris played the hapless, socially inept oddball. It is a confession of active coldness, and the essay’s structure—moving from a family debate about psychics and the possibility that butterflies in the Sussex house were Tiffany trying to make contact, to that devastating closing image—refuses to let the reader, or the author, off the hook. The book does not apologize, and it does not resolve this guilt into a lesson. It simply leaves it there, a stone in the shoe of every subsequent essay.

The rest of Calypso orbits this grief without ever fully landing on it, which is both its formal strength and its limitation. Sedaris’s method is the personal essay in the autobiographical-comic tradition: accumulation of observed detail, family anecdote, overheard conversation, dry declarative humor. The book is not a linear narrative of mourning but a series of topical essays—on his Fitbit obsession, on a wild fox he befriends, on a Tokyo shopping trip with his sisters, on a gastrointestinal virus that threatens to humiliate him on stage—that circle back to the family’s new house on Emerald Isle, North Carolina, and to the slow decline of his ninety-something father. The structure mimics the way grief actually operates in a life that must continue: it erupts, recedes, shows up in the middle of a joke about a snapping turtle, and then disappears into a rant about American small talk.

This approach yields extraordinary passages. The essay “Leviathan” finds Sedaris at the Emerald Isle canal, shadowing a battered snapping turtle he names Granddaddy, while his family argues about his father’s health, scatters their mother’s ashes in the surf, and his father surprises everyone by wearing a Cherokee headdress to Thanksgiving dinner and weeping quietly. The essay “Stepping Out” charts his descent from a Fitbit introduced by a woman in Melbourne into sixty-thousand-step days, twenty-five miles of roadside litter collection, and a body transformed by compulsion—a routine that reads as both a manic assertion of control and a way of walking away from the grief at the center of the book. The essay “The Perfect Fit” takes him to Tokyo with sisters Amy and Gretchen, where they buy absurdly expensive distressed clothing, he practices his Japanese by claiming to be a pediatrician, and the three of them look across a restaurant table and marvel: “Look how our lives turned out! What a surprise!” That moment of mutual astonishment is one of the book’s few unguarded celebrations, and it earns its tenderness precisely because the surrounding essays have been so shadowed.

The political and historical context of the book’s composition—the 2016 election and its aftermath—arrives in “A Number of Reasons I’ve Been Depressed Lately,” a numbered catalogue of grievances that builds toward a Thanksgiving screaming match with his Fox-News-watching father and then a fall from a ladder that fractures eight ribs. Sedaris collapses the two traumas into one: “Both pains persist—show no signs, in fact, of ever going away. The damage is permanent. I will never be the same as I was before the accident/election.” The parallel is characteristically glib, but the essay earns a deeper resonance when it pivots to his father Lou, now ninety-four, living alone in a Raleigh house so filled with hoarded paper that he crawls from room to room by flashlight. In “The Comey Memo,” Sedaris visits Lou, receives a two-year-old calendar and a fox print as gifts, and throws them in an airport trash can—a small act of rejection that reverberates against the larger history of mutual disappointment between them. He concedes that he “wouldn’t have liked my childhood self either,” that he regularly lied, stole money, clogged the toilet for sport. The estrangement, he admits, is not simply his father’s doing; he “froze in that moment” of childhood resentment and never let his father change. When Hugh asks, “Why can’t you let people change?” the question hangs unanswered.

This is where Calypso does its most uncomfortable work. Sedaris has built a career on the comic exaggeration of family dysfunction, and the risk of that mode is that it freezes people into caricatures they can never escape. The book itself enacts this problem: his father is rendered as a collection of obsessions—jazz records, paper hoarding, Fox News—and the rendering is often hilarious, but it is also a way of not seeing the man whole. Sedaris knows this. In a remarkable moment in “The Silent Treatment,” he traces his lifelong inability to make easy conversation with Lou, and the essay becomes a portrait of two men trapped in roles neither chose. The father’s decline, tracked across the book’s timeline, forces a reckoning with the limits of the comic gaze. By the closing essays, Sedaris is imagining the moment of driving away from the Raleigh house forever, and the book resolves, not in reconciliation, but in the quiet decision to accept his father’s useless gifts “with grace”—a choice against anger, against grievance, against the opposition party he has long led.

The other great reckoning is with his mother Sharon, dead of cancer in 1991 at sixty-two. She appears in dreams, “always sixty-two, seated in an empty room,” and in the essay “Why Aren’t You Laughing?” Sedaris sits in a Hawaiian rental signing five thousand tip-in pages for his next book while watching Intervention and remembering his mother’s alcoholism—the cheerful conversationalist by day, the raging, ice-cube-clattering drunk by night. The family’s collective failure is stark: “six kids and a husband, and not one of us spoke up.” He admits he was “drunk too,” that they enabled her with a conspiracy of silence that masqueraded as love. The admission transforms the book’s earlier portraits of family closeness into something more ambiguous. The warmth Sedaris claims for his clan—“we are fundamentally better than everyone else”—is revealed as partly a story they tell themselves to avoid confronting what they refused to see. The pattern recurs with Tiffany: the family’s habit of looking away, of not intervening, of assuming that class “inoculated us against severe misfortune.”

Sedaris is too skilled a writer to let these revelations become maudlin, and the book’s comic engine keeps running even through the darkest material. The essay “And While You’re Up There, Check On My Prostate” is a worldwide survey of traffic curses that is pure vaudeville—the Dutch offering “cancer whore,” the Bulgarians wishing the offender an eternity of kidney stones, a woman from Bucharest delivering the unsurpassable “I shit in your mother’s mouth.” The essay “Calypso” details the removal of a lipoma by a Mexican doctor in El Paso at one a.m. in a roadside clinic, the tumor shipped on ice to his sister Lisa’s freezer with the label “DAVID’S TUMOR”—an anecdote so perfectly Sedaris that it seems invented, though it is not. These essays provide the relief the book needs, but they also reveal its structural weakness. Some of the slighter pieces—“Your English Is So Good,” the riff on American small talk, the Fitbit mania stretched to essay length—feel like filler, the kind of material a writer of Sedaris’s gifts can produce on autopilot. The fox essay, “Untamed,” is lovely in its observation of Carol the vixen, but it also functions as a metaphor so tidy (wild creature, tentative bond, inevitable loss) that it risks sentimentalizing the grief it is clearly meant to hold.

The book’s most significant limitation, however, is the one Sedaris himself names. Tiffany remains a structural absence. He admits, with characteristic candor, that “we didn’t really know our sister very well.” The essays circle her death, return to the moment of turning her away, debate psychics and butterflies, but they never enter her life. This is honest—it would be a different book, and perhaps an impossible one, to attempt to imagine her interiority. But it also means that the central figure of the book’s grief remains a silhouette, defined more by the family’s failure to reach her than by anything we learn about who she was. The book is, in this sense, more about Sedaris’s guilt than about Tiffany, and that guilt, while powerfully rendered, can sometimes feel like its own kind of performance—the comic writer confessing his sins with the same precision he applies to a Japanese shopping spree or a Romanian curse, the self-awareness itself becoming a new mask.

Yet the achievement of Calypso is that it repeatedly lets that mask slip. The moment that best captures the book’s emotional register is not one of grief but of unexpected political joy. In “A Modest Proposal,” Sedaris stands on a West Sussex roadside with a litter picker, reads the headline announcing the Supreme Court’s same-sex marriage ruling, and proposes to Hugh for purely tax reasons. He persists through eighteen refusals, maintains his ironic detachment, and then, standing there, he is “overcome with emotion.” His eyes tear up. He flashes back to a teenage self for whom being gay “felt like the worst thing that could happen to a person.” The studied indifference cracks, and what rushes in is the history the comedy has been managing all along—the shame, the fear, the years when a government would never have recognized his love. That Sedaris can hold both the tax-dodge joke and the genuine tears in the same paragraph is the book’s signature move, and it is what lifts Calypso above his earlier collections. The comic detachment is not abandoned; it is shown to be insufficient, and that insufficiency is the point.

Locate this book within the traditions it inhabits, and it becomes clear how unusual it is. It is memoir, yes, and satire, and personal essay, and queer autobiography, and confessional writing—but it does not fully commit to any of these modes. It lacks the narrative drive of conventional memoir; its satire is too inward, too implicated, to function as true social critique; its confessions are always hedged by wit. The result is a book that belongs to the peculiar American tradition of the humorist-as-moralist—the line that runs from Twain through Thurber and Perelman to Sedaris himself—but with a late-career gravity that the tradition rarely permits. The cross-references the book makes—to Intervention, to The Art of the Deal, to the Obergefell ruling, to the Sandy Hook conspiracy theories his friend spouts—situate it firmly in the specific texture of 2010s American life, but its real subject is older and more universal: what we owe the people we love, and what we do when we discover we have failed to pay it.

Calypso is not a comfortable book, and it should not be mistaken for the breezy comic memoir its cover might suggest. It is the work of a writer who has spent a lifetime turning his family into art and is now confronting the possibility that the art was also a way of turning away. Sedaris remains incapable of writing a dull sentence, and the book’s pleasures—the Tokyo shopping sprees, the Sorry! tournaments, the fox walking beside him in the dark—are genuine. But the book’s lasting effect is not pleasure; it is the uneasy recognition that the person who made you laugh has been showing you, all along, the limits of laughter. Anyone who has outlived a sibling, cared for an aging parent, or wondered whether their own kindnesses are really about being witnessed will find themselves in these pages—not comforted, exactly, but accompanied, and implicated, and told by a voice they trust that the worst thing that can happen to a family is also the thing that happens to everyone.

Notable Quotes

I made up my mind eons ago that I would not let that happen, that I would also die at sixty-two. Then I hit my midfifties and started thinking that perhaps I'm being a bit harsh. Now that I've scored a couple of decent guest rooms, it seems silly not to get a little more use out of them.

Reflecting on his mother's death at sixty-two and his own aging — mortality, middle age, dark humor

Mustn't Tiffany have hoped that whatever pills she'd taken wouldn't be strong enough and that her failed attempt would lead her back into our fold? How could anyone purposefully leave us—us, of all people? This is how I thought of it, for though I've often lost faith in myself, I've never lost faith in my family, in my certainty that we are fundamentally better than everyone else.

Processing his sister's suicide on the drive back from the beach — family, grief, self-awareness, denial

At the end of my first sixty-thousand-step day, I staggered home with my flashlight knowing that now I'd advance to sixty-five thousand and that there'd be no end to it until my feet snapped off at the ankles. Then it'd just be my jagged bones stabbing into the soft ground.

Describing his escalating Fitbit obsession — compulsion, dark humor, middle age

At what point had I realized that class couldn't save you, that addiction or mental illness didn't care whether you'd taken piano lessons or spent a summer in Europe?

Learning that a childhood acquaintance is now homeless in a city park — class, mental illness, disillusionment

It's not that our father waited till this late in the game to win our hearts. It's that he's succeeding.

Observing his father's late-life softening at the beach house — family, aging, forgiveness

Honestly, though, does choice even come into it? Is it my fault that the good times fade to nothing while the bad ones burn forever bright? Memory aside, the negative just makes for a better story: the plane was delayed, an infection set in, outlaws arrived and reduced the schoolhouse to ashes.

Reflecting on why he remembers the negative rather than the positive — memory, writing, negativity bias

I felt betrayed, the way you do when you discover that your cat has a secret secondary life and is being fed by neighbors who call him something stupid like Calypso. Worse is that he loves them as much as he loves you, which is to say not at all, really. The entire relationship has been your own invention.

Learning that his beloved snapping turtle has a name given by local boys — projection, loneliness, self-deception

The battle for gay marriage was, in essence, the fight to be as square as straight people, to say things like 'My husband tells me that the new Spicy Chipotle Burger they've got at Bennigan's is awesome!'

His conflicted feelings about the same-sex marriage ruling — gay identity, conformity, ambivalence

We're like a pair of bad trapeze artists, reaching for each other's hands and missing every time. Meanwhile the stage crew has gathered below us and begun to roll up the safety net.

Describing his inability to connect with his aging father — father-son relationship, communication, mortality

What do other fathers and sons talk about? I'd ask myself, shifting the worklight from one hand to the other. There was never any problem making conversation with my mother. That was effortless, the topics springing from nowhere, and we'd move from one to the next in a way that made me think of a monkey gracefully swinging through the branches of a tree.

Childhood memories of holding the worklight for his father in silence — family, communication, gender roles

He tried doing the same to my sisters and my brother, Paul, but none of them ever heard what he and I did. John Coltrane's 'I Wish I Knew.' Betty Carter singing 'Beware My Heart.' The hair on my arms would stand up, and everything else would recede—my shitty life at school, the loneliness and self-loathing I worried every day might drag me under—all of it replaced by unspeakable beauty.

The one thing that connected him to his father: jazz — music, father-son bond, transcendence

I started seeing people wearing face masks in the airport and decided that I hated them. What bugged me, I realized, was their flagrant regard for their own lives. It seemed not just overcautious but downright conceited. I mean, why should they live?

During the 2014 Ebola panic on his lecture tour — mortality, misanthropy, dark humor

When you're in the state that my sister was in, and that most people are in when they take their own lives, you're not thinking of anything beyond your own pain. Thus the plastic bag—the maximizer, as it were—the thing a person reaches for after their first attempt at an overdose fails and they wake up sick a day later thinking, I can't even kill myself right.

Processing the details of Tiffany's suicide method — suicide, mental illness, grief

I'd come home from Chicago, where I was living, and she would offer to throw a dinner party for my friends... By the time my guests arrived, she'd be wasted. My friends all noticed it—how could they not? Sitting at the table as she repeated a story for the third time—'I got them laughing'—watching as she stumbled, as the ash of her cigarette fell onto the floor, I'd cringe and then feel guilty for being embarrassed by her.

Describing his mother's alcoholism in its later stages — alcoholism, family shame, loyalty

There are things I avoid talking about with my father now—politics, for instance... I don't want what could be the last words we say to each other to be ugly.

After the fight about Trump at Thanksgiving — family, political division, mortality

The fantasy remained active until I was twenty. Funny how unimportant being gay became once I told somebody. All I had to do was open up to my best friend, and when she accepted it I saw that I could as well.

Recounting his years of imagining a wife who would conveniently die — coming out, gay identity, self-acceptance

I insist that Carol eat in my presence for the same reason I wait for the coffee shop employee to turn back in my direction before putting a tip in his basket. I want to be acknowledged as a generous provider. This is about me, not them.

Analyzing his need to feed the fox Carol directly rather than leaving food out — self-awareness, need for recognition, generosity as ego

Six kids and a husband, and not one of us spoke up. I imagine her at a rehab center in Arizona or California, a state she'd never been to. 'Who knew I'd be so good at pottery?' I can hear her saying, and, 'I'm really looking forward to rebuilding my life.'

Regretting that no one in the family ever confronted his mother about her drinking — regret, alcoholism, family failure

I had filled the house that night. I was in charge—Mr. Sedaris. 'The door,' I repeated. 'I'd like for you to close it now.' And so the man did. He shut the door in my sister's face, and I never saw her or spoke to her again.

Confessing the last time he saw Tiffany alive, at a stage door in Boston — guilt, cruelty, irreversible acts

Perhaps, like the psychic, they were just telling me what I needed to hear, something to ease my conscience and make me feel that underneath it all I'm no different from anyone else. They've always done that for me, my family. It's what keeps me coming back.

After confessing about shutting the door on Tiffany — family, guilt, complicity, love

Both pains persist—show no signs, in fact, of ever going away. The damage is permanent. I will never be the same as I was before the accident/election.

Comparing his broken ribs from the ladder fall to the Trump election — politics, grief, permanence of loss

Once, in high school, he was shouting at me for something or other—running too much bathwater, maybe—and I shouted back, 'You are going to die alone!' Isn't that awful? Now here he is, trying to do just that—die alone—and everyone's giving him a hard time about it.

At dinner with Hugh, reflecting on his father refusing to leave his house — cruelty of youth, prophecy, aging